Welcome to Now See This, THR chief TV critic Daniel Fienberg’s weekly viewer guide newsletter dedicated to cutting through the daunting clutter of the broadcast, cable and streaming TV landscape! Comments and suggestions welcome at daniel.fienberg@thr.com.
Crime Keeps on Slipping / Into the Future
I fully understand not everybody will be in a rush to watch an eight-hour docuseries on 250 years of American criminal justice, but Lynn Novick’s Crime and Punishment in America is easily the week’s most essential programming. The Ken Burns-produced series, available on PBS.org and the PBS app, consistently connects the U.S.’s historical deliberations on justice — who makes the laws? Who is impacted by the laws? Can a society be both appropriately punitive and aspirationally compassionate? — with our challenges in the present, covering legal milestones, the evolution of our unique penitentiary system, ongoing conundrums tied to class and race and gender and much more. A good complement to Novick’s excellent College Behind Bars, Crime and Punishment in America is at its best digging into the personal stories beyond familiar headlines, including the plight of the Groveland Four, victims of the system like George Appo and Austin Reed, and Fred Korematsu, who took his resistance to Japanese internment all the way to the Supreme Court. While the series, narrated by Keith David and featuring an A-list roster of voices, feels long and occasionally exhausting (by design), it’s substantive beyond measure.
The Fall and Rise of Trauma TV
From the national trauma of crime and punishment to a season of trauma as the backstory to many of TV’s best dramas … This week, Angie Han and I broke down the highlights and lowlights of fall TV, so if you’ve looking for something to watch over the holiday week or something to discuss with friends and family over turkey and stuffing, we’ve got you covered. We discussed big shows like Netflix East of Eden and CBS’ Cupertino, as well as somewhat under-the-radar favorites like Apple’s Small Prophets and Starz’s Tip Toe(definitely not one to watch if you’re looking for something peppy), plus Netflix’s North of North, my go-to recommendation whenever somebody is searching for something warm, fuzzy and uplifting. And aren’t we all?
ADVERTISEMENT
Oobah Chaka, Oobah, Oobah, Oobah Chaka
Trauma aside, it’s also a big weekend for scams on TV. Angie likes the performances from Anthony Boyle and Julia Garner playing Sam Bankman-Fried and Caroline Ellison, respectively, in Netflix’s The Altruists, but felt that the focus on the main characters’ love story cheapened the drama’s stakes. I didn’t really like the performances either, which scream, “I’m playing a nerd with a funny accent” in Garner’s case and “I’m playing a nerd who’s also Jewish” in Boyle’s. I tapped out somewhere in the third chapter. I was more amused by Oobah: Scams for a Better Tomorrow, premiering on Sunday on HBO. If you don’t know British journalist-prankster Oobah Butler’s thing, he’s like a cross between Nathan Fielder, Louis Theroux and Michael Moore. In this five-part, half-hour comedy-docuseries, Oobah attempts to game the system to find success in the worlds of wellness, wine, dating apps and more. The episodes are rushed, but the results are eye-opening.
Bore-a-Lago
Honestly, I checked out Amazon's Melania: The Series, a two-part follow-up to (or, more accurately, set of outtakes from) the critically reviledMelania, to see if propagandist-in-chief Brett Ratner would be able to do something more humiliating than the part in the feature when he says, "Sweet dreams, Mr. President." The answer? Yes. Coming from Squiggy Riefenstahl, the line, "What I'm hearing from my friends' daughters is that they're in love with Barron" counts as one of the creepiest things ever said on American television. Does Ratner know that you're allowed to edit documentaries? Anyway, I requested screeners for a full review, but Amazon had no interest. So instead, I watched the 37-minute first episode when it premiered today, the timing a comically bad reading of the cultural room given the recent midterms. Yes, it's utter garbage, an artless symphony of sycophancy, but I'm a generous and reasonable critic, so I'll say this: Melania Trump is much more comfortable around the camera in this footage. She actually makes a joke or two. Not funny jokes, but whatever. She's still constantly wearing sunglasses inside and the series maintains the excruciating voiceover from the film, so if you liked that, expect more of the same. If you didn’t, and if you're not a self-flagellating television critic, move on with your life.
Far from the ‘Madden’ Crowd
In terms of quality, it’s a pretty rough week for Amazon. David O. Russell’s Madden, starring Nicolas Cage, Christian Bale and metric tons of latex, is getting ripped to shreds. Our David Rooney calls the Amazon biopic of coaching, TV and video game legend John Madden “cartoonish” and suggests it might be improved by some investment in football, which I can assure you is not the case. I think Madden wants to be a screwball comedy, but is too flat to make that tone work. I couldn’t tell you what attracted Russell to this story, or why he thought this was the best way to tell it. The sports-inclined will probably be happier with Liz Garbus and Elizabeth Wolff’s Give Me the Ball! The Billie Jean King-centric documentary airs Sunday on ESPN under the 30 for 30 banner after its premiere at Sundance in January. Rooney was a big fan, calling it “a thrilling study of tennis greatness and an inspiring salute to a game-changer in women’s rights and LGBTQ visibility.”
Our Critics Take Manhattan
Rooney and the rest of our exceptional film team also offered their take on the 25 Best New York Movies of All Time, ranking an eclectic assortment of cinematic showcases for the Big Apple. It features some unimpeachable classics like Billy Wilder’s The Apartment (streaming on Tubi), The Sweet Smell of Success (Amazon and Mubi) and Rosemary’s Baby (Paramount+); some very impeachable classics like Breakfast at Tiffany’s (Paramount+); and a top choice that, sadly, is only available for rental. I appreciated some of the deeper cut picks, including Peter Sollett’s Raising Victor Vargas and Bill Sherwood’s Parting Glances (both on Amazon), while lamenting the absence of movies in which Muppets or Jason Voorhees take Manhattan. There’s plenty of fun stuff to watch on this thoughtfully curated list.
This email was sent to billboard2@gmail.com by The Hollywood Reporter. Please add email@mail.hollywoodreporter.com to your address book to ensure delivery to your inbox.
Visit the Preferences Center to update your profile and customize what email alerts and newsletters you receive.